Vision:-

An effort to find durable peace for the human-kind on foundation of a philosophy tested by time and experience that has defied fatigue.
You are visitor number:  
Intervention Paper-I
 

Sachar Committee Report
and
The Constituent Assembly
(In Historical Perspective)
 

 

  • Sachar Committee has presented the problems of poverty, unemployment, education and deprivations of different kinds, faced by the people of India in general, as those of Muslims alone.
 
  • It has not only distorted and fuzzed the data but also hidden the fact that in at least Nine States Muslims are better off than their Hindu counter-parts.
 
  • Sachar Committee Report reads like a complaints of complains and demands of Muslims right from Sir Syed's time to 1946. The solutions recommended are the same, which led to the partition of the country.

 
 
Chapter - I Click here... >>>>>
5-8
  
   
Sachar Committee Report
a. Introduction
b. Non-Inclusion of Muslims in the Voters lists
c. Notification of Reserved Constituencies
d. The Meaning
e. Meaning of Sachar Committee Report
f. Notes and References
5
5
6
7
7
8
8
         
 
Chapter - II Click here... >>>>>
9-14
   
Proposal for the Separate Electorates in the Constituent Assembly
a. Introduction
b. Advisory Committee Recommendations
c. Recommendations in the Constituent Assembly
d. Notes and References
9

9
9
9
14
  
         
 
Chapter - III Click here... >>>>>
15-33
  
   
Final debate in the Constituent Assembly
a. Introduction
b. Report of Advisory Committee on Minorities, etc.
c. Debate in the Constituent Assembly
---1. Sardar Vallabhbhai J. Patel
--- 2. B. Pocker Sahib
--- 3. Mohamed Ismail Sahib
--- 4. Z.H. Lari
--- 5. Naziruddin Ahmad
--- 6. Begum Aizaz Rasul
--- 7. Syed Muhammad Saadulla
--- 8. Jagat Narain Lal
--- 9. R.K. Sidhva
--- 10. Muhammad Ismail Khan
--- 11. Jawaharlal Nehru
--- 12. Tajamul Hussain
--- 13. Maulana Hasrat Mohani
--- 14. Col. B. H. Zaidi
--- 15. Sardar Vallabhbhai J. Patel
d. Notes and References
e. Appendix-A
f. Appendix -B
15
15
15

15
18
18
19
19
20
20
20
21
22
23
25
29
29
30
33
34
36
  
         
 
Chapter - IV Click here... >>>>>
38-48
  
   
Roots of Sachar Committee Report
a. Introduction
b. Seeds of Two-Nations Theory
c. Lucknow Pact: Two-Nations Theory Becomes Official
d. Lucknow Pact Dumped
e. Iqbal and Rahmat Ali
f. Lahore Resolution and Jinnah
g. Notes and References
38
38
38
39

40
41
43
45
  
         
 
Conclusions
Click here...
 >>>>>
46